Vox Sang 2000;79(1):40-5
Erythrocytapheresis with recombinant human
erythropoietin in hereditary
hemochromatosis therapy: a new alternative.
Kohan A, Niborski R, Daruich J, Rey J, Bastos F, Amerise G, Herrera R,
Garcia M, Olivera W, Santarelli MT, Avalos JS, Findor J
Departments of Transfusion Medicine and Immunotherapy,
and Gastroenterology,
Hospital de Clinicas, University of Buenos Aires School of Medicine, Buenos
Aires, Argentina. aikohan@intramed.net.ar
===============
Abstract
Background and objectives: The purposes of this study
were to evaluate the tolerance, efficacy and safety of isovolemic
erythrocytapheresis (EA) in nonanemic patients with hereditary hemochromatosis
(HH), and to assess the usefulness of recombinant human erythropoietin (rHuEPO)
associated with EA to reduce treatment duration.
Materials and Methods: In 10 asymptomatic
patients with serum ferritin >400 microg/l, transferrin saturation >50%,
and GPT elevation, EA with rHuEPO and folic acid was performed.
Results: Red cell indices, serum ferritin, and other
iron metabolism parameters (serum iron, transferrin, and transferrin
saturation); GPT and other laboratory data were considerably improved.
Conclusion: This method offers better
results in less time than traditional phlebotomy. EA with rHuEPO is an
effective therapeutic alternative for patients with HH.
====================
Introduction
Hereditary
hemochromatosis (HH) is characterized by excessive iron deposits in various
tissues, associated with increased intestinal absorption. This accumulation may
be 10 or more times greater than usual [1]. The iron overload is toxic [2-5]
and may be potentially carcinogenic [6-8]. Clinically, liver manifestations
(cirrhosis and hepatocellular carcinoma) predominate and may lead to death in
more than 75% of patients [6, 9-12]. Diabetes mellitus and its complications
[10, 13], as well as cardiac diseases [14, 15], may cause death in 10% of
cases. Less frequently, sexual dysfunction, amenorrhea [16-18] and skin
hyperpigmentation may develop. Medical treatments are usually based on iron
remova1 [10, 19, 20] through phlebotomy and chelating agents such as
deferoxamine [21-23], often ill-tolerated, discontinued or with no appropriate
follow-up. Large-volume erythrocytapheresis (EA), described by Kellner and
Zoller [24], has become a useful therapeutic alternative, especially when more
than 1,000 ml of red blood cells can be collected. Recombinant human
erythropoietin (rHuEPO) proved to be effective in promoting hematocrit (VPRC)
and hemoglobin increase in patients with inadequate endogenous production due
to renal failure, or when large volumes of autologous blood must be withdrawn
preoperatively [25, 26]. The purposes of this study were: to evaluate the tolerance, efficacy, and
safety of isovolemic EA in nonanemic patients with HH and
to assess the usefulness of rHuEPO association with EA to reduce treatment
duration.
Materials and Methods
Ten nonrelated
male patients (average age 48 years; range 44-54), seen at the Departments of
Transfusion Medicine and Immunohematology, and Gastroenterology between October
1, 1994, and August 30, 1996, were considered. Cases selected for this study
were those most likely to tolerate regular therapeutic phlebotomy, i.e.,
patients without circulatory overload/hypervolemia, hyponatremia, and markers
of advanced hepatic disease.
Inclusion criteria
were: serum iron > 168 ug/dl, transferrin saturation >65%, serum ferritin
>400 ug/l, and liver biopsy consistent with hemochromatosis. Histology
sections were examined with hematoxilin-eosin, Masson trichrome, and Perls
stains. Iron stores were estimated by the method of Cook et al. [27]. Patients
refractory to regular phlebotomy for more than 1 year were also enrolled.
Exclusion criteria
were: clinical features of circulatory overload and/or hypervolemia (ascitic
edematous syndrome), serum sodium >
130 mEq/l, serum potassium >5 mEq/l, BUN >40 mg/dl, serum creatinine >
1 mg/dl, creatinine clearance < 80 ml/min, alpha-fetoprotein > 15 ng/dl,
alcohol consumption >40 g/day, positive serum markers of viral hepatitis
(HbcAc, HbsAg, and/or anti-HCV) and autoimmunity (ANA, SMA, LKMl, and
anti-mitochrondrial antibodies), anti- HIV, secondary hemochromatosis, or HH
with encephalopathy. The main characteristics of this series were skin hyperpigmentation
(8/10), hepatomegaly (9/10), splenomegaly (5/10), cardiac involvement (5/10),
insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (3/10), glucose overload intolerance
(2/10), gonadal failure (5/10), arthralgia (4/10), asthenia (lO/lO), liver
cirrhosis (10/10), and HLA-A3 (9/10).
EA was prescribed
when the VPRC or hemoglobin reached 34% or 10 g/dl, respectively. The amount of
red blood cells collected was based on the total volume estimated, although in
no case was 30% of the circulating erythrocyte mass exceeded. Starting with the
first EA, all patients received rHuEPO, 4,000 units subcutaneously, three times
a week (approximately 150 U/kg/week), and folic acid, 10 mg/day per os.
Red cell indices
were assessed weakly, before and after each EA; serum ferritin was measured
every other week, while other iron metabolism parameters (serum iron,
transferrin, and transferrin saturation), GPT, y-GT, AP, total protein, alpha
1-, alpha 2-, betha-, and y-globulin, se-um glucose and BUN, were evaluated
monthly.
EA therapy was
deemed complete when iron metabolism values returned to normal and remained
steady for more than 30 days.
A manually
operated, discontinous flow cell separator in one-way mode (Haemonetics V50
Plus) and a continous flow cell separator in two-way mode (Excel-Dideco) were
used. Before each procedure, a physical examination was performed. In patients
with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus, serum glucose levels were measured
before, during, and after EA.
A superficial vein
of the forearm was punctured and 500-1,000 ml of 0.9 g/dl NaCl, according to
the estimated erythrocyte volume to be removed, were infused. Blood was
collected (50-70 ml/min) in ACD- A solution (sodium citrate, 1.64 g; citric
acid, 0.6 g; dextrose, 1.84 g, in 500 ml), at a ratio of 12:1 to 14.1.
EA consisted of
three phases: (1) blood collection and blood product, separation; (2)
isovolemic normal saline administration to replace the removed volume, and (3)
autologous plasma and buffy-coat infusion. The adjusted erythrocyte volume
withdrawn was defined as the total volume multiplied by its VPRC.
Results
Laboratory
findings before and after EA are compared in table 1; reticulocyte and
hemoglobin data for each patient over time are illustrated in figure 1.
Adjusted red blood
cell volumes collected in each EA and after treatment has been completed are
shown in table 2.




In each EA, a median reduction
of 11% (range 6-17) for VPRC and of 3.3 g/dl (range 1.8-5.9) for hemoglobin was
noted. The median interval between EA, necessary for VPRC and hemoglobin levels
to reach 34% or 10 g/dl, respectively, was 9 days (range 3-14). A monthly
median of 3.1 EA (range 2.4-4.4) was obtained, and 2,098 ml (range 1,648-3,677)
of red blood cells could be collected.
Biochemistry parameters of
body iron reached nonnal values within 3 months. The median duration of
treatment needed for serum ferritin to return to normal levels was 3.25 months
(range 1.0-7.5). When these levels exceeded 2,000 ug/l, more than 6 g of iron
could be withdrawn. Serum ferritin changes are shown in figure 2. Serum CPT
declined in parallel with ferritin and proved to be a valuable indirect index
of tissue iron depletion. A 38-51% reduction of iron deposits was documented
(table 3).

Clinically, skin pigmentation
was considerably attenuated. Liver and spleen enlargement was also diminished;
in 1 patient (case 3), splenomegaly persisted and was associated with
thrombocytopenia. This insulin-dependent diabetic patient could be later
controlled with diet only, and in case 2, insulin doses could be reduced in
approximately 50%. Except in case 2, with impotence for 10 years, the sexual
dysfunction disappeared. Arthralgia also receded, and the general status
improvement allowed patients to resume their daily activities.
Hepatic biopsies obtained 30
days after EA therapy was completed showed a net reduction of iron contents
(from grade 4 to grade l or 0) and no inflammation. EA was generally well
tolerated and discontinuation was never required. Only orthostatic hypotension
after the fIrst EA was noted, but no treatment was needed. All patients
reported fatigue after the procedure.
Discussion
HH results from an excessive intestinal absorption of iron, which
accumulates in tissues and produces systernic lesions that may be irreversible,
particularly when diagnosis is delayed [28-32]. These lesions appear to be
related to the duration and amount of iron stored [33, 34]. To reduce iron
overload, several approaches may be used. In patients with iron overload caused
by multiple transfusions, the chelating agent deferoxamine is frequency
employed. In HH, deferoxamine administration is limited to patients with
anemia, difficult venous access, unstable cardiovascular status, or endocrine
diseases, in whom phlebotomy or EA cannot be done. In addition, deferoxamine therapy
to deplete iron deposits is significantly protracted and expensive; it may
require several years in HH and is usually taken for life by chronically
transfused patients. The drug is injected subcutaneously and is associated with
adverse effects that often lead to intolerance and poor compliance [35]. Oral
iron chelators may become a valuable alternative as adjuvants designed to
reduce the period of time necessary to deplete iron deposits and partially
revert HH manifestations; however, these agents are not yet available for
clinical use [36-40].
Classically, HH was
treated with regular phlebotomy. During this procedure, 180-220 ml of red b1ood
ce1ls may be collected; considering that 1 ml of red blood cells contains 1 mg
of iron, approximately 200 mg of iron may be removed with each blood unit. In
our experience, this is not the case. In fact, HH patients usually require
weekly phlebotomies, and although sustained iron elimination is obtained, in 7
days VPRC or hemoglobin levels cannot return to normal. Consequently, withdrawn
volumes are considerably less than 200 ml, efficacy is often overestimated, and
the period of time needed to reduce the iron overload is protracted (from 1 to
3 or more years).
Regular phlebotomy is a
useful, rather simple and affordable option for HH patients [21]; however, in
symptomatic cases, 100 or more procedures may be required [41]. In addition, a
good venous access must be available. In many instances, frequent venipunctures
are not well tolerated and lead to discontinuation of treatment [10,21].
Moreover, phlebotomy also extracts plasma, platelets, and white blood cells,
and therefore, the clinical status may worsen.
In recent years, EA has been
successfully used to collect massive amounts of whole blood. When performed with
strict adherence to procedural standards, it has demonstrated to be effective
and safe for patients with polycythemia vera, porphyria cutanea, erythropoietic
porphyria, and, central retinal vein thrombosis [42-44].
In 1989, Conte et al. [45] reported a study of
patients treated with EA and confirmed its value to collect red blood cells
only. However, volumes were similar to those obtained with phlebotomy (200-250
ml), reduction of iron deposits was not accelerated, and frequent venipunctures
were not avoided.
In 1992, Kellner and Zoller
[44] described a prospective study of 8 patients with HH, who underwent
repeated isovolemic large-volume EA (1,000 ml) with 28-day intervals. Around 1
g of iron could be removed in each EA. Serum ferritin level decline started
after 60 days and returned to normal within 12 months, thus showing a
significant difference with classic phlebotomy and chelating agents. This
finding may be explained by the bone-marrow-induced mobilization of iron
deposits in response to lower circulating hemoglobin levels. Induced anemia
normally augments endogenous erythropoietin synthesis; an up to sixfold
increase in erythropoiesis may occur [45] and hemoglobin may return to normal
in 30 days. rHuEPO has proved to be highly effective in elevating hemoglobin
levels when endogenous production is low (chronic renal failure) or even when
it is normal, to promote erythropoiesis for preoperative collection of
autologous blood [25, 26].
In our series, serum GPT
values decreased in parallel with ferritin, whereas transferrin saturation and
serum iron remained increased almost up to the end of EA therapy. This
observation suggests the following hypothesis: it is well known that iron
metabolism is based on its mobilization in three compartments: tissues (deposit),
serum (ferritin) and erythropoiesis (utilization). Large red blood cell volume
removal and rHuEPO-induced erythropoietic estimulation promote iron deposit
utilization.
During this stage, ferritin
levels decline as a result of reduced iron deposits. This iron is released from
tissues as free iron, which is rapidly used to maintain serum iron and
transferrin saturation levels. This event may explain the co-existence of iron
deposit depletion and high levels of serum iron. Consequently, drops in serum GPT
and ferritin may result from tissue iron depletion and iron injury. Therefore,
serum GPT may be used as a indirect marker of iron deposit reduction.
In our study, a median red blood cell volume of 475 ml (range 400-1,400 ml) was removed in each EA; a median of 3.1 (range 2.4-4.4) EAs/month were performed, and approximately 2,000 ml of red blood cells/month could be withdrawn. EA with rHuEPO removed a volume more than three times higher than phlebotomy; moreover, the period of time needed for serum ferritin to return to normal was considerably shorter than expected according to the litera- ture data (3.5 months versus more than 12 months) [21,46, 47]. EA with 28-day intervals, as described by Kellner and Zoller [24] could collected a mean of 1,010 ml in each procedure, during a mean of 8.5 months, whereas in our series, red blood cell volume removal could be doubled and the period of time required for iron deposits to return to normal was reduced by more than 50%. In both cases, side effects were similar and not significant.
After EA therapy is completed,
serum ferritin and transferrin saturation are measured monthly during the first
year and at 6 month intervals thereafter. If any of these parameters increases,
EA is resumed to prevent tissue injury. In patients with HH and low serum
albumin levels and/or thrombocytopenia, weekly phlebotomies may aggravate the
problem. In patients with HH and water and electrolyte imbalance, EA with 5%
dextrose may be used.
EA may seem expensive and
demands adequate equipment and a trained staff, but in our series, the period
of time needed to deplete iron deposits, HH risks and working day losses were
sensibly reduced. Cost-effectiveness must be evaluated in the context of all
factors involved in the treatment of HH and its complications.
Conclusion
In our experience, EA with
rHuEPO and folic acid is a well-tolerated and useful procedure to reduce iron
deposits and thus totally or partially correct associated dysfunctions. This
method offers better results in less time than traditional phlebotomy and is an
effective therapeutic alternative for patients with HH
References
1 Balan V, Baldus W, Fairbanks V, Michels V,
Burrit M, Klee a: Screening for hemochromatosis: A cost-effectiveness study
based on 12,258 patients. Gastroenterology 1994; 107 : 453-459.
2 Weinberg ED, Weinberg aA: The role of iron in
infection. CUff Opin Infect Dis 1995;8: 164- 169.
3 Weinberg ED: Iron withholding: A defense
against viral infections. Biometals 1996;9, in press.
4 Britton RS: Metal-induced hepatotoxicity.
Sernin Liver Dis 1996;16:3-12.
5 Riggio 0, Montagnese F, Fiore S, et al: Iron
overload in patients with chronic viral hepatitis: How common is it? Am J Gastroenterol
1997;92:1298-1301.
6 Tavill AS: Hemochromatosis; in Schiff L,
Schiff ER: Disease of the Liver. Philadelphia, Lippincott, 1993, pp 669-{;91.
7 Weinberg ED: The role of iron in cancer. Eur
J Cancer Prev 1996;5:19-36.
8 McCord JM: Iron, free radicals, and oxidative
injury. Sernin
Hemato11998;35:5-12.
9
Priest R, Beck J: HemoCromatosis; in Bockus RD (ed): Hemocromatosis en
Gastroenterologia. Barcelona, Salvat, 1981, v01 3, pp 485-505.
10
Adams PC, Speechley M, Kerteaz AE: Long- term survival analysis in hereditary
hemochromatosis. Gastroenterology 1991;101:368-372.
11
Pietrangelo A: Metals, oxidative stress, and hepatic fibrogenesis. Semin Liver Dis 1996; 16:13-30.
12
Arora AS, Gores GJ: The role of metals in ischemia/reperfusion injury of the
liver. Semin LiverDis 1996;16:31-38.
13
Tavill AS, Bacon BR: Hemochromatosis: Iron metabolism and the iron overload
syndromes; in Zakim D, Boyer TD (eds): Hepat010gy: A Textbook of Liver Disease.
Philadelphia, Saunders, 1990, pp 1273-1299.
14
Buja L, RobertS W: Iron in the heart: Etiology and clinical significance. Am J
Med 1971;51: 209-212.
15
Vigorita V, Hutchins a: Cardiac conduction system in hemochromatosis: Clinical
and pathologic features of six patients. Am J Cardiol 1979;44:41&-423.
16
Adams P, Kertez A, Valberg L: Clinical pre- sentation of hemochromatosis: A
changing scene. Am J Med 1991;90:445-449.
17
Bezwoda W, Bothwell T, van der Wallt T, et al: An investigation into gonadal
function in patients with idiopathic hemochromatosis. Clin
Endocrinol1977;6:377-384.
18
Bothwell TH, MacPhail PM: Hereditary hemochromatosis: Etiologic, pathologic, and
clinical aspects. Semin Hematol 1998;35:55- 71.
19
Bomford A, Williams R: Long-term results of venesection therapy in idiopathic
hemochromatosis. Q J Med 1976;45:511-523.
20
Niederau C, Fisher R, Sonnenberg A, et al: Survival and causes of death in cirrhotic
and non-cirrhotic patients with primary hemochromatosis. N Engl J Med
1985;313:1256-1262.
21
CohenA, Witzelban C, Schwartz E: Treatment of iron overload. Semin Liver Dis 1984;4:228- 238.
22
Crawford DHG, Halliday JW: Current con- cepts in rational therapy for
hemochromatosis. Drugs 1991;41:875-882.
23
Kicking HM: Treatment of chronic iron over- load. Clin
PharrnacoI1991;10:775-783.
24
Kellner H, Zoller WG: Repeated isovolemic large-volume erythrocytapheresis in
the treatment of idiopathic hemochromatosis. Z Gas- troenteroI1992;30:780-784.
25
Goodnough LT, Rudnick S, Price TH, et al: In- creased preoperative collection
of autologous blood with r-HuEPO. A controlled trial. N Engl I Med
1989;321:1163-1168.
26
Shinonaga M, Hayashi I, Shinada S, et al: Ef- fect of r-HuEPO on
reduction of homologous blood transfusion in open heart surgery. Kyobu Geka
1990;43:276-279.
27
Cook ID, Skikne BS, Lynch SR, et al: Esti- mates of iron sufficiency in
the US population. Blood 1986;68:726-731.
28
McLaren CE, McLachlan GI, Halliday IW, Webb SI, Leggett BA,
Iazwinska EC, Craw- ford DH, Gordeuk VR, McLaren GD, Powell LW: Distribution of
transferrin saturation in an Australian population: Relevance to the early
diagnosis of hemochromatosis. Gastroenterology 1998;114:543-549.
29
Adams PC, Valberg LS: Evolving expression of hereditary hemochromatosis. Sem
Liver Dis 1996; 16:47-54.
30
Adams PC, Gregor IC, Kertesz AE, Valberg LS: Screening blood donors for
hereditary hemochromatosis: Decision-analysis model based on a 30-year database.
Gastroenterology 1996;109:177-188.
31
Bacon RR: Diagnosis and management of hemochromatosis. Gastroenterology 1997 ;
113:995-999.
32
Umbreit IN, Conrad ME, Moore Ea, Latour LF: Iron absorbtion and cellular
transport: The mobilferrin/paraferritin paradigm. Semin HematoI1998;35:13-26.
33
Scheuer PJ, Lefkowitch JH: Disturbances of copper and iron metabolism; in
Scheuer PJ, Lefkowitch JH (eds): Liver biopsy interpretation. London, Saunders,
1994, pp 218-228.
34
Borwein ST, ahent aN, Aanagan PR, Cham- berlain MJ, Valberg LS: Genetic and
pheno- typic expression of haemochromatosis in
Canadians. Clin Invest Med 1983;6:171-179. 35 Rose C, Cambie C, Mahieu M, Forzy a, et al:
Deferoxamine stability in common intra- venous
solutions ASH Annual Meeting, San Diego,1997.
36
Hershko C: Oral iron chelating drugs: Coming but not yet ready for clinical
use. Br Med J 1988;296:1081-1082.
37
Hershko C: Iron chelators in medicine. Mol AspectsMed 1992;13:113-165.
38
Oliveri N, Brittenham a, Matsui D, et al: Iron chelation therapy with oral
deferiprone in patients with thalassemia major. N Engl J Med 1995;332:918-922.
39
Nathan D: An orally active iron chelator. N Engl J Med 1995;332:953-954.
40
Grady RW, Giardina PJ: Oral iron chelation: Further progress with HBED
(abstract 2747). ASH Annual Meeting, San Diego, 1997.
41
Olynyk JK, Luxon BA, Brit ton RS, Bacon BR: Hepatic iron concentration in
hereditary hemochromatosis does not saturate or accurately predict phlebotomy
requirements. Am J Gastroenteroll998;93:346-350.
42
Kaboth U, Rumps K, Lipp T, et al: Treatment of polycytemia vera by isovolemic
large-volume erythrocytapheresis. Klin Wochenschr 1990;88:18-25.
43
Spengler F, Zoller W: Erythrocytapheresis: A new effective tool for treatment
of central venous thrombosis of the eye. Plasma TherTrans
TechnoI1986;7:139-142.
44
Zoller W, Kellner H, Spenger S: Erythrocyta-pheresis: A method for rapid
extracorporeal elimination of erythrocytes. Results in 85 pa- tients. Klin
Wochenschr 1988;88:404-409.
45
Conte D, Mandelli C, Cesana M, et al: Effectiveness of erythrocytapheresis in
idiopathic hemochromatosis. Report of 14 cases. Int J
Artif Organs 1989; 1 :59-82.
46
Legget BA, Halliday JW, Brown NN, Bryant S, Powell LW: Prevalence of
hemochromatosis amongst asymptomatic Australians. Br J
HaematoI1990;74:525-530.
47
Phatak PD, Cappuccio JD: Management of hereditary hemochromatosis. Blood Rev
1994; 8: 193-198.